Civicord · UK · Browse / Labour Party / Edinburgh South West / Scott Arthur

Campaign site for Scott Arthur (Labour Party — Edinburgh South West), scraped April 2025, audited September 2026.

Scott Arthur

Labour Party
parl.2024-07-04

View evidence Before and after Propose a correction Is this your record? Claim it Reply if this is wrong More change stories ↗See what you follow Query The Graph

Snapshot audit, not a current availability check. HTTP success and surname matches do not prove campaign content survived. On-chain fields are on Sepolia testnet; full content is not stored on-chain.

URLs responding — Scott Arthur's recorded URLs returned successful HTTP responses at the 2026-09-07 audit. This does not establish that campaign content survived.

Labour Party: 61% responding across the party · this candidate: responding.See the cohort ↗

Stood in Edinburgh South West — 2 of 3 sites responding (67%) · 1 unreachable · 1 redirected

S14000081 · Scotland · Scotland · 73,315 electorate · Halftone: more / larger paper dots = lower response rate.

View Edinburgh South West ↗Filtered ledger — 3 sites ↗

Apr 2025scraped
→
Sep 2026audited
→
PendingSepolia

Before and after

April site-wide text vs the 2026-09-21 homepage fetch of https://drscottarthur.scot: 0 sentences still present, 10624 no longer found, 6 new. These are candidates for review, not proof a sentence was withdrawn.The April text covers the whole scraped site; the later text is one homepage fetch. A sentence can be missing from that homepage and still exist on another page. A missing sentence is not matched to a replacement.

The snapshot lists 5 of 10624 sentences that were not found. The rest are counted, not quoted here.

Before · April 2025

By the time they were removed in 1957, there were 47 miles of network. - Edinburgh Trams was named ‘Global Light Rail Operator of the Year 2017’ and the UK’s best transport operator for customer satisfaction. - Our trams are among the most advanced in Europe, offering a fast, safe, and reliable serv

transport

After · 21 September 2026

Not found on the homepage fetch.

https://drscottarthur.scot

Gap: no replacement sentence is matched. The April text covers the whole scraped site; the later text is one homepage fetch. A sentence can be missing from that homepage and still exist on another page.

Before · April 2025

This includes a business continuity grant fund to help alleviate short-term cash flow issues, dedicated business development champions, business upskilling, logistics hubs, customer service officers, extra help to keep the area clean and attractive and technological solutions to help local business

After · 21 September 2026

Not found on the homepage fetch.

https://drscottarthur.scot

Gap: no replacement sentence is matched. The April text covers the whole scraped site; the later text is one homepage fetch. A sentence can be missing from that homepage and still exist on another page.

Before · April 2025

Any further work to complete an area will be done under localised traffic management with no need to close the entire area again - It is anticipated that all construction work will be complete by summer 2022 with testing and commissioning then taking approximately 6 months When do you expect the Tra

After · 21 September 2026

Not found on the homepage fetch.

https://drscottarthur.scot

Gap: no replacement sentence is matched. The April text covers the whole scraped site; the later text is one homepage fetch. A sentence can be missing from that homepage and still exist on another page.

Before · April 2025

What input has Lothian Buses had to the final business case in terms of the impact on their business? - The Council have worked closely with Lothian Buses during the development of the final business case. - The Council will continue to work with Lothian Buses closely in developing traffic managemen

transport

After · 21 September 2026

Not found on the homepage fetch.

https://drscottarthur.scot

Gap: no replacement sentence is matched. The April text covers the whole scraped site; the later text is one homepage fetch. A sentence can be missing from that homepage and still exist on another page.

Before · April 2025

The methodology used ensured that the 370 people who were interviewed were a fair reflection of the demographics of the local area. - The outcomes of the survey were very encouraging, especially considering that this research exercise was carried out ahead of the extensive public consultation and en

After · 21 September 2026

Not found on the homepage fetch.

https://drscottarthur.scot

Gap: no replacement sentence is matched. The April text covers the whole scraped site; the later text is one homepage fetch. A sentence can be missing from that homepage and still exist on another page.

New on the later homepage, not matched to a removed sentence

Dr Scott Arthur MP – Subscribe to my newsletter to stay up to date on my work in Parliament and Edinburgh South West Skip to content Dr Scott Arthur MP My Work News and Media My 5 Focus Areas Surgeries About me Resources FAQs Get in Touch Dr Scott Arthur MP Member of Parliament for Edinburgh South W This sentence is only on the later homepage. No April sentence is matched to it. 21 September 2026 · https://drscottarthur.scot
Read more September 21, 2026 Uncategorized Devolution Must Mean More Than Holyrood: It’s Time to Empower Local Government Read more September 20, 2026 Blog My Week In Parliament – 14th 18th September 2026 Read more September 18, 2026 September 18, 2026 Stay Updated Subscribe to my newsletter to get devolution This sentence is only on the later homepage. No April sentence is matched to it. 21 September 2026 · https://drscottarthur.scot
Subscribe Skip to content ↓ Subscribe Subscribed Dr Scott Arthur MP Join 52 other subscribers Sign me up Already have a WordPress.com account? This sentence is only on the later homepage. No April sentence is matched to it. 21 September 2026 · https://drscottarthur.scot
Privacy Dr Scott Arthur MP Subscribe Subscribed Sign up Log in Report this content View site in Reader Manage subscriptions Collapse this bar This sentence is only on the later homepage. No April sentence is matched to it. 21 September 2026 · https://drscottarthur.scot
No issue is too big or too small for me to take up, so if you think I can help, please get in touch! This sentence is only on the later homepage. No April sentence is matched to it. 21 September 2026 · https://drscottarthur.scot

Propose a correction

If a URL, name, or sentence on this record is wrong, send a sourced request. It is queued for a person to review. It does not change the audit, the April scrape, the sentence comparison, or the Sepolia record.What is verified, and what is not.

Review queue

Requests stored for this record. A request is not an edit.

Is this your record?

If you are Scott Arthur or work on their campaign, you can claim this record. Say how a reviewer could verify it — a campaign-domain email, a link on the live site, or your Democracy Club profile. A claim is queued for a person to check; it grants no edit access and changes nothing until verified.

Websites

Respondinghttps://drscottarthur.scot

What changedURL redirected at the audit

HTTP result: Responding (HTTP 200) at the 2026-09-07 audit
↳ Redirect destination at audit: https://scottarthurmp.wordpress.com/
Candidate-name signal: surname matched in the response body (heuristic only)

Source evidence and excerpts

These are short excerpts from the April 2025 scrape, not the later wording and not complete archived pages. Original filenames identify the stored extracts. Browse the Campaign Lab source dataset ↗

Scrape excerpts — April 2025 · 8 shown

Page	Chars	Opening excerpt
content_645.html	42,354	Below are 70 frequently asked questions and answers from the Council. They cover a wide range of commonly asked question…
content_181.html	40,911	Update (21-05-22) – Linked here are notes from a meeting myself and David Houston (Colinton Community Council) held with…
content_418.html	40,911	Update (21-05-22) – Linked here are notes from a meeting myself and David Houston (Colinton Community Council) held with…
content_118.html	39,756	Below is a Council briefing in the Draft NPF4 – it is a “is a long-term plan for Scotland that sets out where developmen…
content_59.html	39,756	Below is a Council briefing in the Draft NPF4 – it is a “is a long-term plan for Scotland that sets out where developmen…
content_407.html	22,265	I cycled a lot as a child after learning to ride on a friend’s Raleigh Chopper. This was mainly with a second hand bike …
content_399.html	22,265	I cycled a lot as a child after learning to ride on a friend’s Raleigh Chopper. This was mainly with a second hand bike …
content_506.html	20,179	Below is an update on the data the Council holds in relation to the 20 mph scheme – including a number of streets in my …

Agent viewInspect the data and verify the recordGraph live

The audit ledger above is a static snapshot. The buttons below run live queries against The Graph and the ledger JSON — only when you click them. Nothing fetches automatically and nothing here is mocked.

1 Free ledger JSON

/api/candidates/19814.json

Static audit record — websites, status, ENS hint.

2 WebMCP join

Preferred agent tool — live Graph + ledger verdict.

compare_onchain_to_ledger(id="19814")
-> { onchain, ledger, verdict[] }

3 The Graph (live)

On-chain p19814.civicord.eth via/api/graph (Studio proxy) — person id, not seat slug.

{
  candidate(id: "19814") {
    id ensName status url personName textRecordCount
    registeredAt registeredAtBlock owner
  }
  _meta { block { number } hasIndexingErrors }
}

Live queries run on demand; a failure is shown honestly, never replaced with a cached response. Verify independently: ENS ·resolver ·Subgraph Studio ·/api/graph ·openapi.yaml ·source